- Most Helpful
- Highest Rating
This is truly VERY easy and VERY delicious. I made this because this week the produce guy had key limes. I started squeezing them by hand, but soon figured out that a half of a key lime will fit in my garlic press. And the holes are small enough that you don't have to worry about the seeds. (Just a tip if you have happen to want to use fresh key limes.)
This was so quick and delicious. I only used a little over 1/2 a cup of key lime juice because I ran out but I thought it was too tart; I add 2 Tablespoon of sugar because it seemed so tart but after it was cool it actually tasted just right. I made a homemade gluten free shortbread crust to go with this. Will make again. Note-- key limes are essential not the persian limes!
Excellent with homemade crust and real whipped cream!
good stuff! I did it in lemon.. it was divine. Thanks for sharing!
Wanted to make a Key Lime Pie for dinner but had no eggs. So glad I found this. This pie is soooooooo delicious. Great flavor, light and smooth tasting. Really liked the tangy lime taste. Used a shortbread crust. Will be making again for sure.
Make this with a chocolate wafer crust instead of graham cracker...Delish!
I was pleasantly surprised at how good this was. When I started mixing the s/c milk and the cream cheese together, it seemed like there was SO MUCH s/c milk... and it was so runny with all that lime juice. I made it around noon and we had it at dinner, and it was only kind of set. It set a lot more by the next day. My husband loved it.
Incredibly delicious and so simple all the ladies thought I slaved â€¦well squeezing all those little limes was tedious and time consuming, but well worth it! I put this in a pretzel crust and used a little zest from the limes to give it a punch of that key lime flavor. This is the only key lime pie I will ever make again no need to look further for better.
So quick, easy, and delicious! The fastest key lime pie I've ever made. Actually, my 8 year-old made it, I just supervised. Used fresh limes, cause I had a lot to use. Also nonfat sweetened condensed milk and lowfat cream cheese. Worried that the pie wouldn't be set enough, since it contains no eggs and is unbaked, but it was perfect. Topped with just a bit of whipped cream at serving. My kids absolutely inhaled this! Thanks for sharing the recipe!
My husband is a big fan of key lime pie (I am not so much). We both agreed that this deserves 5 stars because it is soooo fast and easy. But if I had been in the kitchen for 2 hours putting this together it would have been 3.5 stars. I topped it with fresh whipped cream laced with a bit of ground cinnamon. Thanks it was yummy!